Alumni

The Prep Legends

Honoring Significant & Lasting Impact

Throughout the long history of Seton Hall Prep, countless individuals have made a significant and lasting impact on the school and in their communities. The Prep Legends Series honors alumni, faculty and friends whose lives and accomplishments embody the spirit and values of our community. Each Legend has had a significant impact, not only on their professional life, but also on the lives of those around them.

More details to be announced in the Fall of 2026! Stay tuned on this page for more.

Thank You 2026 Sponsors

Diamond Sponsor:

Beneficia Farm – The Salerno Family

Champagne Sponsor:
The Barnitt Family – Rich '80, Dave '81, Pat '85 & Chris '88

Gold Sponsor:

Clifford J. Boan, Esq., USMC '97
Gregory J. Castano Jr. '85
Michael Filippello '87
Ted Haack '87
John and Kathleen McTague '66
JD Methfessel '07
Vincent & Patricia Nascone P'08, P'10, P'13, P'20
Brian Newman '94
The Hersh Family - Zack '15, Brandon '20 & The Mottesi Family - Nico '17, Daniel '20

Advancement Office

List of 5 members.

Mr. James Boyle

Director of Institutional Advancement

(973) 736-6861
Mr. Matthew N Nesto 12

Director of Alumni Relations

(973) 325-6634
Mr. Peter A Durning 06

Director of Activities
Ms. Madison Kilduff

Director of Engagement
Theodora Cipollone

Advancement Coordinator

(973) 325-6633

The Prep Legends

List of 2 items.

About

Founded in 1856, Seton Hall Prep has a long, rich history. The profound impact the school, its faculty and alumni have had on the world is immeasurable. However, you can see it wherever you look. Whether it is in the world of business, medicine, theater, music or science to name a few, you will find a connection to Seton Hall Prep. During a conversation in March 2024, in Burbank California, the idea for The Prep Legends Series was born. It is the hope that by recognizing the outstanding accomplishments of past graduates, faculty, staff and friends, present and future members of the school and its community will strive to higher achievements like the honorees bestowed The Prep Legend’s title.

The inaugural presentation happened on September 27, 2025, with the festive celebration of Joe Neglia H’01. Though he was not an alumnus, he has been so devoted to the school and is a lifetime advocate for the performing arts.

It is with special thanks and accolades to Peter Basler ’91, Kenneth Waddell ’85 and Kevin Michael Smith ’78 that The Prep Legends Series was converted from an idea to reality.
Mission

Established in 2024, The Prep Legends Series was created to honor alumni, faculty, and friends of Seton Hall Prep who embody the virtues of Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton who, like our honorees, was a selfless spirit. The Prep Legends Series celebrates the significant impact honorees have made in the areas of academic excellence, service and leadership in the school or community, and outstanding professional or personal achievements. Their accomplishments are exemplary and tangibly demonstrate the core values that define Seton Hall Prep.